Okay...so I stumbled across After Tonight by accident. I heard it playing on a MySpace page and could not get the song out of my head. I then downloaded the song...because I loved it. Then Amazon offered the song Criminal as a free download. Well I snapped that one up. I too thought this would be a CD with 1 or 2 songs that I liked...so I you-tubed him. I wasn't overly impressed but the good reviews on this site swayed me to buy his CD. I was blown away with Justin's talent. I can't believe he was a teenager when he recorded this. It took me several times of listening to really appreciate the entire CD...and appreciate it I do. Justin's voice speaks for itself. My personal favorites are After Tonight, Criminal, Golden Train, I'm in Peace, Oh Mamma, and Be Back Soon. I like Save Him as well...but I try not to listen to it because it made my cry when I first heard it. Every time it comes up on the playlist, I let the refrain play once and then quickly change it because my eyes start to water. If you're wondering whether you should buy the CD...do as I did, and you-tube him. His songs are all there for you to listen to. Then when you buy his CD, you'll know that you're getting yourself into some crazy good music.