I so happy that she decided to show who she really is in this video

finally no bootie shaking s***

I love this video it means your true 2 your yourself and you are not perfect and you have flaws and i love the video and i like the moves she in the video it was different and i have the deluxe cd and i listen 2 it everyday and i love the video i listen everyday on my ipod and my second favorite is beafiul liar with shakira i love her 2 and i have all of beyonce music videos on the anothlogy i love it watch it everyday...

your biggest fan i cant wait to your concert... going me and my friends

cicely pastor kiss & hugs ...xoxo

This video seems to show the real Beyonce'.

The melody of the song was too repetitive. "Thats why I love you..." started to get on my nerves. When the video ended I did not have the urge to replay it.

this is a great video. Love the black and white. Amazing song.

This video got to be Beyonce's best one. The lirycs are touching and beautiful, the melody adds power to the song, and the video is just amazing, I felt that Beyonce was really having fun and enjoyin the whole thing, more than i could feel in any of the other videos

I commend Shakira and Beyounce to crossing over to each other’s fan base to create a wonderful song called “Liar”. This is song is where both artists’ fans can relate to: being lied to. If you did not notice they both look similar, so its like watching twins. I know men will like that!

I would like to know when they would do it again. I wish them much success on this single.

i really like the video!!!!

even though i dont bang with beyonce like that i like the song

THE SONG iS GREAT BUT HONESTLY...THE ViDEO BORES ME